A roof replacement is a major expense for most Fairfield County homeowners. The contractor you pick decides whether it protects the house or leaks. This page gives you a step list to run before you sign anything.
How We Researched This Page
We are a referral service, not a roofing contractor. See About and the disclaimer for what that means.
On October 23, 2026 we read the government pages linked below. This summary covers only what those pages say.
No attorney reviewed it. Neither did an insurer or building official.
What Licenses and Insurance Does an Ohio Roofing Contractor Need?
Ohio does not issue a general statewide residential roofing license. Bills to add one were proposed, but we could not confirm any were enacted. Some cities and counties require local registration or permits.
Check current rules with the Ohio Construction Industry Licensing Board and your local building department. Then ask each contractor for insurance proof, local registration, and references.
General liability insurance. This covers damage to your property during the job. Ask for a certificate of insurance (COI) naming you as additional insured.
Have the insurer email it to you directly.
Workers' compensation. Ask for proof of Ohio Bureau of Workers' Compensation (BWC) coverage. An insurer COI alone is not enough.
Then check it yourself.
The BWC Employer/MCO look-up checks whether an Ohio employer has workers' compensation coverage. You can search by employer name, policy number, federal tax ID, or SSN.
BWC notes that policy status is based on information it has at search time. It can change after payment reporting and validation. BWC lists 1-800-644-6292 if you cannot find an employer.
Source: Ohio BWC Employer/MCO look-up.
We did not open a BWC page describing the certificate itself. So treat a paper certificate as a starting point. A contractor with no employees should say so in writing.
Some crews work as subcontractors. Get written confirmation that the umbrella coverage under the general contractor extends to your job.
What Does a Legitimate Roofing Quote Look Like?
A real quote is written, not a verbal ballpark. Get at least three. Each should contain these items:
- Scope of work: shingle layers removed, areas reshingled, valleys, ridges, hips
- Materials: manufacturer, product line, and color. "30-year shingles" could mean dozens of products
- Accessories: underlayment type and brand, ice and water shield, drip edge, flashing scope including step flashing, chimney flashing, and pipe boot replacement
- Permit: who pulls it and who pays
- Decking allowance: the rate if damaged decking is found at tear-off, and whether they call you first
- Cleanup and haul-away
- Labor warranty and payment terms: length in writing, deposit amount, final payment timing
Quote gaps often come from scope differences, not contractor quality. Compare identical scopes. A quote missing line items is not a low bid.
It is an incomplete scope.
How Do You Check a Contractor? A Step List
Work through these steps in order. Each ties to a source you can open.
- Call the building department. The Ohio Attorney General says to check with local officials on whether permits are required. Ask whether roofers must register and whether yours is on file.
- Ask for proof of insurance. The Attorney General lists proof of licenses, insurance, and bonding. For workers' comp, run the BWC look-up above.
- Call references. The Attorney General says to check the references a contractor gives you. Ask about price, schedule, and cleanup.
- Check the Better Business Bureau. The Attorney General suggests checking your local BBB at bbb.org. Also compare the volume and recency of online reviews.
- Verify manufacturer status. GAF and Owens Corning run online contractor locators. We could open only the Owens Corning page. Confirm any badge a contractor claims, then ask what warranty it allows.
- Get everything in writing. The Attorney General advises against starting a project unless all details are in writing. It also says the contract should not require a large down payment.
- Know your cancellation window. In a home solicitation sale, the buyer may cancel "prior to midnight of the third business day." Seller notice rules apply. See Ohio Revised Code 1345.23.
What Do Local Building Departments Say About Contractors?
Rules differ by city. We opened the Lancaster pages, but found no re-roof rule. Confirm with the department.
The Lancaster contractor page says most contractors register with the Building Department. That involves a $15,000 surety bond and proof of liability insurance. It also says "City ordinance mandates you hire a registered contractor."
The Lancaster Building Department page says you must obtain a permit before work begins. It links to a current registered contractor list. It also links permit forms.
| Lancaster Building Department | Phone listed by the city |
|---|---|
| Main office | 740-687-6649 |
| Inspection requests | 740-681-5018 |
Ask three things. Does a re-roof need a permit at my address? Must the contractor register?
Is mine listed?
Pickerington lies partly in Fairfield County and partly in Franklin County. Confirm with the city building department which office handles your address. No Pickerington contractor page was opened, so no rules are stated for it.
What Are the Biggest Red Flags with Roofing Contractors in Ohio?
Pressure right after a storm. Door-to-door canvassing and demands to sign now are warning signs. Legitimate local contractors are busy after storms too, but they just don't work that way.
Offers to waive your deductible. Ask your insurer before agreeing to anything.
A pending Ohio House bill, H.B. 769, would bar contractors from advertising deductible waivers.
The sponsors' May 26, 2026 release says it awaited committee action. Check its current status.
Quotes without an inspection. A price given by phone or from a photo is a guess. Expect add-ons later.
A large deposit. Some deposit is normal because materials must be ordered. Pay the final balance only after you've walked the finished job.
Same-day pressure to sign. "This price is only good today" is a sales tactic.
No local presence or references. Treat a contractor with no verifiable Fairfield County history with caution.
What Questions Should You Ask Before Hiring a Roofer?
"Will you pull the permit yourself?" The contractor should pull and close it. Unpermitted work can complicate a home sale.
"Who will be on my roof?" Ask whether crews are employees or subcontractors. Ask whose insurance covers them.
"What if you find rotted decking?" You want a per-sheet or per-foot rate. You also want to know if they stop and call first.
"Will you register the manufacturer warranty?" Some installers never register it. Ask for the warranty certificate.
What Does a Good Roofing Warranty Look Like?
A complete warranty has two parts, and both matter.
Manufacturer warranty (materials). Architectural shingles carry a limited warranty against material defects. Terms vary by product line, so read the document.
Enhanced warranties usually require a certified contractor.
Contractor warranty (workmanship). This covers flashing errors, missed nails, and bad underlayment installs. Get the length in writing.
A short term leaves you alone if a flashing leak appears.
Transfer and exclusions. Ask whether the warranty transfers if you sell, and at what fee. Watch for cosmetic damage exclusions and per-claim caps.
Related reading: our Lancaster contractor guide and avoiding roofing scams in Ohio. For pricing, see Ohio roof replacement costs for 2026.
What Should a Roofing Contract Include Before You Sign?
A quote is not a contract. The contract should list:
- The contractor's legal name, address, and any local registration number
- A line-item scope, not a lump sum
- Total price and payment schedule
- A start date and completion window, not "a few weeks"
- Written manufacturer and workmanship warranties
- Cleanup details and who handles the permit
Long start dates are not a red flag on their own. Storm season creates real backlogs. No start date and no completion window is the problem.
Should You Sign an Assignment of Benefits?
We advise against it. An Assignment of Benefits (AOB) transfers your insurance claim rights to the contractor. You lose control of your own claim.
Ohio does not ban AOBs. A contractor can work your insurance job without one. If one insists, ask your insurer before signing.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Ohio require roofing contractors to be licensed?
Ohio does not issue a general statewide residential roofing license. Some cities require local registration or permits. Lancaster, for example, publishes a registered contractor list.
Confirm with your building department.
How do I verify a roofer's workers' compensation?
Ask for proof of Ohio BWC coverage. Then search the BWC Employer/MCO look-up by name, policy number, or tax ID. Policy status can change, so check close to the start date.
How much deposit is normal?
Some deposit is normal because materials must be ordered. The Ohio Attorney General says a contract should not require a large down payment. Pay the balance after the job passes your walk-through.
Can I cancel a roofing contract after signing?
For a home solicitation sale, Ohio Revised Code 1345.23 allows cancellation. You have until the third business day ends. Read your contract's notice of cancellation.
How many quotes should I get?
Get at least three written, itemized quotes. Compare identical scope, materials, and warranty terms.
Need Help with Your Roof?
Request an itemized estimate through the Fairfield County contractor referral service.
- Door-to-door solicitation right after a storm
- Cash-only payment required
- Out-of-state plates with no local address
- No physical Ohio business address
- Offers to waive your deductible (ask your insurer first)